Remember When The Platters Remember when. I first met you. My lips were so afraid, to say "I love you". Remember when, to my surprise. The heaven in my heart, leaped into your eyes. Remember how much I cried. Tears of joy to think you were mine. Darling, down deep inside. I still feel that feeling divine. I loved you then, and I still do. I can't remember when, I didn't love you. Remember how much I cried. Tears of joy to think you were mine. Darling, down deep inside. I still feel that feeling divine. I loved you then, and I still do. I can't remember when, I didn't love you.